SHOULDER REST YES OR NO SHOULDER REST
Your browser doesn't support HTML5 audio
Shoulder rest yes or no shoulder rest
Playing the violin requires both skill and proper equipment, and one of the most contentious pieces of equipment in discussions among violinists is the shoulder rest. While some performers swear by this accessory, others prefer to go without, citing the possibility for negative effects on their playing technique and posture. In this article, we'll take a closer look at the pros and cons of using a shoulder rest, as well as tips and techniques for playing without one, so that you can make the best decision for your own playing style and goals.
The use of a shoulder rest with the violin is a relatively recent development, with the first commercial shoulder rest appearing in the early 20th century. Prior to the introduction of the shoulder rest, violinists generally held the instrument without any additional support or padding.
There is some evidence that musicians in the Baroque period may have used some sort of improvised support, such as a cloth or pad, to help hold the violin in place. However, these were not standardized or widely used, and the tradition of playing the violin without a shoulder rest continued through much of the Classical and Romantic eras.
The first commercial shoulder rest for the violin was developed by Otto Musica in the 1920s. This early shoulder rest was designed to be adjustable and comfortable, and it quickly gained popularity among musicians. Over time, other companies began producing their own versions of the shoulder rest, and today there are many different types and styles available.
The introduction of the shoulder rest has had a significant impact on the way violinists play and approach the instrument. It has allowed for greater comfort and stability while playing, and has also opened up new possibilities for sound projection and resonance. However, the use of a shoulder rest remains a matter of personal preference, and many musicians continue to play without one.
The use of a shoulder rest has been a topic of debate in the world of violin playing for decades. Some benefits of using a shoulder rest include the support and stability it provides, which can help prevent strain on the neck and shoulder muscles. However, some violinists argue that a shoulder rest can hinder the natural movement and contact with the instrument, thus hindering the development of proper technique. Here are some pros and cons of using a violin shoulder rest:
Pros
➤ Increased comfort and stability: a shoulder rest can provide more support and stability for the violin, making it easier to hold and play for longer periods of time without experiencing discomfort or fatigue.
➤ Better sound projection: using a shoulder rest can help improve the sound projection and resonance of the violin by allowing the instrument to vibrate more freely.
➤ Personalization: shoulder rests come in a variety of shapes and sizes, allowing musicians to choose one that fits their body and playing style.
Cons
➤ Interference with natural sound: some musicians argue that a shoulder rest can interfere with the natural sound of the instrument by dampening vibrations and resonance.
➤ Limitation of movement: a shoulder rest can limit the range of motion of the player’s left arm, making it more difficult to change positions or play in higher positions.
Ultimately, the decision to use a shoulder rest comes down to personal preference and playing style. Some musicians find a shoulder rest to be an essential accessory, while others prefer to play without one. It’s important to try different options and find what works best for you and your playing.
Holding the violin without a shoulder rest requires a slightly different technique than holding it with a shoulder rest. Here are the basic steps for holding the violin without a shoulder rest:
➤ Start by resting your chin on the chinrest. The chinrest is the curved piece of wood or plastic in the lower left corner of the violin.
➤ Tilt the violin slightly to the left so that the neck rests in the space between your collarbone and left shoulder.
➤ Use your left hand to support the weight of the violin by holding the bottom of the instrument. The left hand should grip the instrument with the thumb on the back of the neck and the fingers curled around the front of the violin.
➤ The left arm should be relaxed and slightly bent, with the elbow pointing down and the wrist straight. The fingers of the left hand should be placed on the strings to play notes, while the thumb remains behind the neck for support.
Remember to take breaks and adjust your position as needed to avoid strain or discomfort. It may take some practice to find the most comfortable and secure position for holding the violin without a shoulder rest, so don't be afraid to experiment and make adjustments as needed.
Here are some tips for maintaining proper posture and avoiding discomfort:
➤ Position the violin so that it rests securely between your collarbone and shoulder, with your chin resting on the chin rest. The angle of the violin should be adjusted so that your left hand can easily reach all the notes on the fingerboard.
➤ Use your left arm to support the weight of the violin, rather than holding it between your chin and shoulder. This will help prevent strain on the neck and shoulder muscles.
➤ Keep your left hand and arm relaxed, fingers bent and wrist straight. Avoid gripping the instrument too tightly or bending the wrist, which can cause pain or injury.
➤ Take regular breaks and stretches to prevent stiffness and fatigue. It may also be helpful to practice in shorter sessions, gradually building up to longer periods of playing.
➤ If you experience pain or discomfort, stop playing and take a break. Consult an instructor or health care professional if the pain persists or worsens.
By following these tips and maintaining proper posture and technique, you can enjoy playing the violin without a shoulder rest while minimizing the risk of injury or discomfort.
Some violin soloists choose to play without a shoulder rest because they believe it allows for greater freedom of movement and a more natural, resonant sound. Without a shoulder rest, the instrument can be held closer to the body, which some musicians feel allows for better control and a greater sense of connection to the music.
Additionally, playing without a shoulder rest can be a way for a musician to connect with historical performance practices, as it was common for violinists in earlier eras to play without a shoulder rest.
It’s important to note, however, that the decision to play with or without a shoulder rest is a personal one, and there is no right or wrong answer. Many successful soloists use a shoulder rest, among others Itzhak Perlman, Hilary Hahn, Joshua Bell, Anne-Sophie Mutter, Maxim Vengerov, Janine Jansen, Sarah Chang, Nicola Benedetti and Ray Chen. Many others prefer to play without one, among others Jascha Heifetz, Isaac Stern, Nathan Milstein, David Oistrakh, Mischa Elman, Fritz Kreisler, Yehudi Menuhin, Kyung-Wha Chung, Gidon Kremer and Viktoria Mullova. Ultimately, the choice should be based on what makes the musician feel most comfortable and expressive while playing.
Playing without a shoulder rest requires a different technique than playing with one. One technique involves supporting the violin's weight with the collarbone and chin, while using the left hand and arm to balance the instrument. This technique allows for greater freedom of movement and flexibility in the violinist's playing. Another technique involves using a sponge or cloth to help balance the violin on the collarbone. Learning to play without a shoulder rest can take time and patience, but it may be worth it for those seeking a more natural and expressive sound.
Playing the violin without a shoulder rest can offer many benefits to the musician. One of the most notable advantages is the freedom it allows for the left hand. With no shoulder rest in the way, the fingers can move more independently, giving the musician greater control over intonation and expression. Additionally, playing without a shoulder rest can help to train the fingers to be more precise and agile. The left hand must work harder to support the weight of the instrument, which can lead to greater finger strength and dexterity.
While using a shoulder rest on the violin might work for some people, others find it uncomfortable or cumbersome. Luckily, there are alternatives to shoulder rests that can provide similar support without the hassle. For example, some violinists choose to use a sponge or foam pad instead of a shoulder rest. These pads can be cut to the right size and shape for each individual player and can be held in place with rubber bands. Another alternative to shoulder rests is a chin rest that is higher than average. Some violinists find that they can comfortably support their violin with just their chin and collarbone, eliminating the need for a shoulder rest altogether.
When playing violin without a shoulder rest, it is important to have a chin rest that is positioned correctly. A chin rest that is too low can put extra strain on the left arm and hand, while a chin rest that is too high can cause discomfort or even pain in the neck and jaw. If you are planning to play violin without a shoulder rest, it is worth taking the time to test out different chin rest positions and styles until you find one that works well for your unique playing style and body shape. An experienced violin teacher can also help you choose the right chin rest based on your individual needs.
One alternative to both shoulder rests and foam pads is the Kreddle cushion. This cushion is designed to sit on the collarbone and provide support for the violin without putting pressure on sensitive areas of the body. It is adjustable in height and angle so that it can be customized to fit each player’s body. According to some violinists, the Kreddle cushion is comfortable, durable, and easy to use. Many believe that it provides a better experience than shoulder rests or foam pads, allowing players to focus on their music without being distracted by discomfort or awkward positioning. If you are interested in the Kreddle cushion, it is important to research the product thoroughly and read reviews from other violinists who have used it. You may also want to consult with a violin teacher to determine whether this product is right for you.
Playing the violin without a shoulder rest can be uncomfortable at first, as it requires more effort to hold the instrument correctly. Here are some tips to help relieve pressure on your shoulder:
➤ Use a sponge or cloth to cushion the violin between your shoulder and chin.
➤ Adjust the tilt of your violin to find a comfortable position.
➤ Try adjusting the position of your left hand to change the angle of the violin.
➤ Relax your shoulders and take breaks when you feel tension.
Playing without a shoulder rest takes time to get used to, but it can greatly improve your playing. Here are some strategies for improving your playing without a shoulder rest:
➤ Focus on maintaining a relaxed posture with both hands and arms.
➤ Slowly increase the amount of time you play without a shoulder rest.
➤ Seek advice from experienced violinists or a music teacher.
When playing without a shoulder rest, there are some mistakes that are common among beginners. Avoid these mistakes to improve your playing:
➤ Pressing the violin too hard against your neck, causing tension.
➤ Using too much pressure with your left hand, resulting in poor intonation.
➤ Having a tense posture, making it difficult to play with fluidity.
➤ Not using the full weight of your arm to draw a clear sound from the instrument.
Remember to take your time when learning to play the violin without a shoulder rest. With practice and patience, you’ll be able to play comfortably and confidently without one.
Hi, I’m Maite, this blog’s author, violin teacher and modern/baroque violin specialist. Read more